Tip Tackle

Absolute RUBBISH
No way a red- yellow at a push

Crazy decision

Giteau moved himself in the air, machenaud's body language never inclined any hint of maliciousness

not about intent,was it reckless?

never go on feet in a tackle like that. focus on feets and stay down or that may be the consequence

giteau tried to protect himself as he fell but it ended up wrong- yellow at the most

If giteau didn't flail around like that we might have seen a penalty but no more. Giteau messed up, and so did the red

Machenaud would have been able to put Giteau down safely had there not been 2 other toulon players in the tackle. Yellow for me, not a red

To anyone who this agrees on the card he swing then picks him up and drives down on the player (spread tackle) and the way giteau landed was too dangerous ref is completely right as for you all get a law book

It's not rugby league, he landed on his head!! Red card

Who filled in at 9?

Imhoff